Fort Monroe stands at Old Point Comfort, where in August 1619 the White Lion brought the first enslaved Africans recorded in English Virginia; in May 1861 General Benjamin Butler's refusal to return three freedom seekers made the fort Freedom's Fortress. Slavery runs through most of Virginia's places. Bacon's Castle in Surry County, the oldest documented house in Virginia, was seized by followers of Nathaniel Bacon in 1676, and in the 19th century the Hankins family enslaved people there. In Williamsburg, Declaration signer George Wythe enslaved people at the George Wythe House, most of whom he freed in 1787, and Colonial Williamsburg's research counts 27 people enslaved in Peyton Randolph's household at the Peyton Randolph House.
Richmond adds the Old Stone House at the Edgar Allan Poe Museum, the city's only surviving colonial-era house, where Poe never lived, and Hollywood Cemetery, where Presidents James Monroe and John Tyler and Confederate president Jefferson Davis are buried. In Virginia Beach, Ferry Plantation House is linked to Grace Sherwood, tried by water as a witch nearby in 1706 and pardoned at a reenactment at the house in 2006.
Several Virginia stories travel through one writer, L. B. Taylor Jr., whose retellings name few witnesses. Colonial Williamsburg's own historian calls the versions of Lady Anne Skipwith's death in the Wythe House legend unfounded, and no contemporary report we saw supports Hollywood Cemetery's 'Richmond Vampire'. At Fort Monroe, a resident's 1960s sighting of a uniformed man was reported in a 2009 Army magazine article.