The battlefields we have researched span more than eighty years of fighting: the 1776 battle at Fort Moultrie, the 1811 battle at Tippecanoe, the 1836 siege of The Alamo, the 1842 Battle of Salado Creek beside Victoria's Black Swan Inn, and the Civil War. The Civil War places include Chickamauga, the first national military park, Kentucky's Perryville, the Gettysburg boulder field called Devil's Den, and two Franklin, Tennessee, houses: Carnton, used as a Confederate field hospital, and The Carter House, the farmhouse where Fountain Branch Carter enslaved 28 people and around which the battle was fought.
The history of these battles is thoroughly recorded. The ghost material is far thinner. Most of the stories we traced are legends without named witnesses, and several were spread by books or signs: the Devil's Den lore largely through a former ranger's books from 1991, and Tippecanoe's slight lore through a former park sign rather than any Native tradition we could find. At Chickamauga, Old Green Eyes has no fixed form at all.
A few accounts can be traced. A former Chickamauga park historian described a tall figure vanishing in 1976, and the Alamo's earliest report is an 1894 newspaper story from the years when part of the building was a police station, though no witness is named. At Perryville, park staff, a local paranormal group and a TV crew describe mostly sounds, such as a drumroll and cannon fire. At Carnton, every report we found is anonymous or a photograph.